6 July 2009

Book Review: Just The Three Of Us by Clare Dowling


Geri and Bob have a good marriage, or so they both thought. They have 2 children, have good jobs and a nice home. But when Bob meets Debs by chance in a sandwich shop near work, sparks fly and the two embark on an affair, without Geri being any the wiser of course. Debs loves Bob very much and wants him to be a part of her life,  but Bob is of course far more reluctant.

But as things begin to get serious for Debs and Bob, will their sudden relationship survive the scrutiny, and is Geri ever going to find out that it's more than just the two of them in her marriage?

I have read several of Clare Dowling's books after discovering her a few years ago, and my favourite to date has been Going It Alone, which was the novel released before this one. Dowling is very successful in her home country of Ireland, but seems relatively unknown in the UK which is a shame as her books are definitely up there with other great Irish authors such as Marian Keyes, Sinead Moriarty and Melissa Hill. This book is Dowling's 7th novel, the fourth of hers I have read and is out now in hardback, and in November in paperback.

The idea of this plot is a good one - seeing an affair from both sides of the story and the way it affects all of the relationships involved but there was a major problem for me. I found the tone of the whole book was just too depressing, and there was nothing happy going on to counter-act the misery of the characters which in turn made it hard to keep reading in parts. Although Dowling has tried to tackle some important issues in the book as well, these just add to the sombre tone of the book and I just felt at times it was all too much and had to pick up something more light-hearted to cheer me up a bit!

The narration is told in the third person which allows for quick and easy changing of story, as it tends to alternate every couple of chapters with who it is following. We first meet Debs who is single and desperate to find a man and prove to her mother she can find herself someone nice to settle down with. The progression of the relationship with Bob is good, and nothing happens unrealistically, but I just couldn't like it because of how wrong it was. She was likeable enough at the start, but I didn't like the direction she went in and therefore I really didn't like her parts of the story, and sort of wanted to skip them.

Geri wasn't a perfect character but I could sympathise with her because of her situation. Dowling writes with real heart as Geri's side of the plot progresses and I couldn't help but feel so sorry for her as her life as she knows it crumbles before her. The way her character is deeply affected is quite hard to read at times, and I credit that to the talented writing of Dowling because she really brings home how infidelity can ruin a family. Other characters pop up but none of them are worth mentioning here as they aren't vital to the plot but just pad out other scenes.

What I did enjoy about the book was the writing style. Dowling's books are always easy to read because of the nice folowing language, and good pacing of the story but this wasn't good enough to outweigh the overly depressing nature of the story for me. As I mentioned, Dowling does try to tackle a very serious issue in the book (not the affair) and while this is very well done and is very informed, it's perhaps just too much for what is already an unhappy storyline. After all, how much happiness can be gotten out of a book about infidelity? If you're a fan of Dowling's work, you'll want to read this but if you  haven't tried her before, I'd recommend trying Going It Alone - much happier and an easier read!

Rating: 3/5

1 comment:

  1. I've never read Clare Dowling before. I was gonna get this one, but I mmight start off with going at alone instead!
    Great Review btw! x:)